I (24M) am kind of wondering if there’s a class of people out there who were effectively immune to patriarchal conditioning because they had loving, secure parents who told them that it was all bullshit and they went on to become loving, secure adults.

I fell for it because I had abusive parents who made me feel that my needs were a burden, and society’s “man up” attitude and contempt for male vulnerability reinforced that message. I was unable to trust anyone or find women attractive because I saw everyone as a threat and believed that they would all be hostile towards me if I revealed my emotional needs. Every instance where I saw men presented as the “strong” gender reinforced my fears.

I could not feel safe around others until I knew that men and women didn’t have fundamentally different ways of thinking and feeling, and to do that, I had to slowly dismantle every “fact” I learned about the “male brain” versus the “female brain” and the gender binary. I also had to learn about and accept my emotional needs, including the loving and emotionally vulnerable sex I wanted that looked nothing like mainstream porn.

Only now, after more than a decade of gradually shedding my Christofascist indoctrination and becoming a radical socialist, do I finally feel safe enough to experience attraction and the desire for romance. I just turned 24, and I started deprogramming at 13.

So, was there just a large contingent of people who never fell for any of this garbage? The male brain vs female brain essentialist nonsense, sex-negative purity culture, the gender binary, the lack of emotional intimacy in porn, and the patriarchal trash everywhere? How can so many people love and respect each other and be normal with all these ideas floating around in society, unless some people were highly resistant to them?

I feel like there are a lot of progressive people on Lemmy who are secure in themselves and always had it right. And they can just find love and make friends in a healthy way, blissfully ignorant of all of the people and ideas that belong on c/AreTheStraightsOK.

What are your experiences?

  • AskewLord@piefed.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    2 days ago

    Yes, but I got punished for it relentlessly. I still do. I am not attractive to women because I don’t confirm to male gender expectations, even though physically I am very male and attractive.

    It’s not ‘falling for garbage’ it’s how society works. People impose roles and expectations on each other. Non-conformity is punished, not celebrated. And IME the ‘anti gender’ people are some of the worst people about this.

    • I think your philosophy is likely more repelling than any gender presentation. The number of people of all genders who would quickly snatch an opportunity to date an attractive feminine man is stupidly high (why do you think so many people gush over Link?)- but your mindset has to shift if you ever wish to be invited into those crowds

      (Not entirely sure what you mean by anti-gender either, do you mean anti-gender norms?)

      • AskewLord@piefed.social
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        20 hours ago

        Those people all think I’m a trump voting redneck. because they judge you entirely on how you look and where you are from.

        and frankly, i don’t want to be around them because they are so miserable and whiny and entitled. they live to be offended and aggrieved, and that’s not my hobby. and they are often trust funders.

        I’d rather be alone than constantly harassed and judged, thanks. I also am not rich, but everyone assumes that I am, and reacts bitterly when they find out I am not.

    • sprigatito_bread@lemmy.worldOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      2 days ago

      By “falling for garbage,” I mean internalizing shame for gender non-conforming traits (e.g. you feel that you’re defective because you’re a guy who likes wearing dresses or fantasizes about being sexually submissive or the little spoon) OR generalizing and believing that everyone will enforce gender roles uniformly (e.g. believing no woman will ever love you because of your gender non-conforming traits). In the former case, you carry constant self-hatred around and want to hide yourself, and in the latter case, you effectively become an incel or misanthrope, believing that everyone else is horrible and bigoted and not worth bothering with. Both cases lead to isolation.

      Bigoted people with backwards views on gender will exist no matter what, but how you respond to that bigotry is a different question. You can recognize that a lot of people have backwards ways of thinking without swearing off humanity entirely or believing you have to change to appease the most people. I feel stupid for breaking and allowing myself to become an incel because I’m nothing like the stereotypical man. It took a decade to dig myself out of that pit. I’m wondering if others were more resilient because they had people in their lives who loved them unconditionally.

    • Starya67@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      2 days ago

      Most women don’t want men who “confirm to male gender expectations” because that usually involves treating women like shit.

      • sprigatito_bread@lemmy.worldOP
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        1 day ago

        I think there are a lot of stereotypical male traits that many women find appealing that don’t involve treating them like shit.

        Having someone who desires and pursues you, who sweeps you off your feet, who emotionally supports you or defends you when you are vulnerable, who’s handsome and confident… none of these inherently involve abusing women or neglecting their needs, and that’s the problem: a woman can easily find these traits attractive while being repulsed by a man displaying neediness and vulnerability – men crying, wanting to be the little spoon or the bottom/submissive one in bed, wanting to present in a more stereotypically feminine manner, or opening up about his anxiety or sadness…

        I believe that there is a patriarchal concept of a “good man” that is appealing to many women precisely because it meets their emotional needs and makes them feel safe. But in order to fulfill that role, a man has to neglect his own emotional needs, because to open up and be vulnerable would be to compromise his attractiveness; he must constantly be the “strong one.” He must be the top, the big spoon, emotionally composed, and he must conform to a certain aesthetic of male attractiveness. If he deviates from this role, he is considered a “weak man” and is not seen as safe or attractive.

        The idea that women generally expect men to be like this is a much harder claim to refute than “women want men who treat them like shit,” especially if you come from a more conservative area, and it is one that has fucked with me personally since the very beginning. It is absolutely possible to be a good boyfriend and husband while adhering to these patriarchal standards, but it requires emotional self-sacrifice and conformity. Because I didn’t want to make that sacrifice, I swore off romantic relationships entirely and never challenged these beliefs until very recently.

        I don’t think like this anymore, but I want to point out that the issue is a lot more nuanced and it’s easy to fall into a pattern where you feel generally excluded or unattractive to women because you are unwilling to conform to that role.