cross-posted from: https://feddit.org/post/24735701
See also:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemini_(protocol)
It is similar to the old gopher: text files, links, and images form a hypertext optimized for reading. Text is formatted like Markdown - but even simpler.
Clients display text, like an eBook, or images / media.
Servers can run on a PC or Raspberry Pi which needs half a Watt of power. No FAANG companies needed. No expert knowledge needed - not more difficult than running a file sharing client.
I think it is the right thing for defense of democracy and sharing your voice in the digital realm.
Edit: If you see comments here which kinda miss the point, appeal to emotions, have faulty logic, or depart from entirely incorrect assumptions: Please keep in mind that big US tech companies can’t say “that’s bad, how will we shovel money with this?”. Please use your critical thinking skills - they are much needed here!
What upsets me about these projects is that they are never mentioned in fmhy.net
Out of curiosity, how do you find gemini sites to read? If there aren’t forms I assume there isn’t a search engine?
See section 2.2 of the FAQ
https://geminiprotocol.net/docs/faq-section-2.gmi
Thete are aggregators. For example
gemini://warmedal.se/~antenna/
or gemini://rawtext.club/~sloum/spacewalk.gmi
gemini://gemini.circumlunar.space/capcom/
or comnunity interest sites, like
gemini://tilde.green/ ,
which is in turn a site of
gemini://tildeverse.org
https://gemini.tildeverse.org/
Then there are systematic directories, like
gemini://medusae.space/
and search engines like
gemini://geminispace.info/
see section 2.2.3 of the above FAQ.
But that’s not modern. Most websites need to recreate basic HTML functionality with a GB of javascript libraries. iow. cut that unnecessary out and internet will become a better experience while saving much storage, throughput, and dissipated energies at every substation.
I’ve used gemini before. It’s pretty neat. Reminds me of old school internet
I’ll just pop in here to add a link to my favorite Android Gemini browser: Rosy Crow
It’s fully featured, even supporting tokens for authenticated sessions.
Wow, very nice! Runs well under SailfishOS !
This reminds me of RSS, designed for reading and pared back to the minimum required to deliver the message and nothing more.
minimum required to deliver the message and nothing more
Wait, that’s not fair! How will Google make money from that!?
RSS feeds, my beloved. The firefox extension Livemarks, restores Firefox’s old RSS capabilities, and it’s so great
What capabilities?
A work of Aaron Swartz, if I remember correctly. Don’t forget him.
That’s a very unfortunate name for the project, given Google’s AI Gemini.
https://codeberg.org/boredsquirrel/dupes
The Gemini Protocol was there way before
Yeah, I can for my life not think of a reason why Google named it like that.
(The Gemini protocol discussed here is from June 2019, the Google language model and chatbot initially called “Bard” from 2023.)
Funny enough I wasn’t too sure what this was about either, figured it was about Google’s AI or maybe it was a protocol for decentralized cryptocurrency blockchain tech. The Gemini cryptocurrency exchange has been around since 2014 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemini_(cryptocurrency_exchange)).
There’s just too many things named Gemini.
There are just too many things named Gemini
Here is a mnemonic for that: The port number of the open source Gemini protocol is 1965, which is the year of the first crewed flight of NASAs project Gemini, the first humans in space.
NGL, saw the name and almost just ignored it
Ah, and one little useful tidbit for Emacs users:
Emacs has a builtin client of course. It also dislays images.
Just
guix install emacs-elpherthen restart Emacs and
M-x elpherI’ve looked into Gemini before. It seems neat but it also seemed like a lot of the links and clients for it on the main info site were dead.
I use Lagrange and it works like a dream
Sounds interesting, what is the benefit of this compared to HTTP though? You can still host text or basic html that way and it works on any web browser.
what is the benefit of this compared to HTTP though?
For me, it’s kind of the novelty of it. Gemini is separated from the mainstream internet, there’s a mild barrier to entry, so it has a distinct culture and vibe to it
Mild is an understatement. It’s likely beyond the ability of most people to set up. To the extent it’s exclusionary.
I mean, to make a website, that’s probably true. But accessing the Gemini protocol is as simple as installing a web browser
Writing a page means editing a file with a simple syntax like markdown (called gemtext).
Running a gemini server is about as difficult as running a file sharing client.
There are pre-built server packages as part of Debian and its derivatives.
Or, one can install Rust and download and build the agate server. That’s what I did on my Raspberry Pi B. That Raspberry has an Ethernet port and USB port which can power it from my FritzBox. Needs half a Watt of Power when idle. Then, one needs to start the server on bootup. This is done via a service file for systemd.
And after that, one only has to configure a folder for the gemini page files, and configure the home router to allow access to that port of the Raspberry Pi.
The alternative is to get a shell account to a shared gemini server like tildeverse. This is usually free of cost since the software is almost maintenance-free and the power draw is a few Euros per year for the entire server.
Gopher guarantees readers that there will never be anything other than text and media served on a site. They don’t have to trust the publisher, the protocol enforces it.
It is much more lightweight and simpler: While you can, but typically won’t write HTML directly with a text editor, you can and typicall would write gemtext markup manually like markdown.
You can run it on a small rasberry pi, using a server like agate, which automatically generates certificates, and if you fancy, you can write your own client browser in a weekend (that’s why there are a lot of clients).
It is very deliberately designed to be minimalistic, to depart from the enshittified modern web flooded with ads, tracking, and slop.
And because of this, pages load instantly.
Myself, I have witnessed the birth of the World Wide Web, designed by Tim Berners-Lee at CERN, to share information, new ideas and knowledge, and run the first Mosaic browser in 1994, and gemini is very close to the hearth of this original idea.
All HTML and PHP I have written was with a text editor but fair point most people don’t. I still would love to see more cool simple sites like bigclive.com
can work on any web browser
Gemini can have competition of browsers: it’s feasible for one person to create a Gemini client completely, correctly and securly.
There are only ~2 web browsers left and making a new one at all is near impossible (forks with minor size changes are great n’ all but not meaningfull enough to stop Google basically being in control).
There is a lot of browsers that can show HTML websites though, not just 2. There are even new ones made like https://chawan.net/.
There are only ~2 web browsers left
And the only widely used browser not owned by big tech has about 2.2% market share now. And it is falling.
Gemini does less than nothing to solve this though?
One problem is that with this monopolization of the web, browser vendors like Google can yank the standard in any direction they like (for example for more tracking and more ads, or surveillance). And you can’t make another browser because the protocol and features are needlessly way too complex, so it is legally an open standard but practically not. In the end, everyone will have to use Googles browser and suffer the included tracking.
aye I’m with you, though for practical purposes currently Gemini seems a lot like throwing the baby out with the bath water
Seperating the modern web browser into discrete parts and each doing them well seems to be the only logically answer to me. (If we ignoring the task of convincing the general public to do anything in their best interests). We already have dedicated video/music player software on our OSs.
That might be the right thing if the bath water is toxic.
It provides a way to share “web” pages (text, images, links) that can be read by a simple minimal client. Without needing a web browser
I think ladybird has been making good progress
See also point 1.1.2 in the FAQ:
1.1.2 The gentler answer for everybody else
Gemini is a group of technologies similar to the ones that lie behind your familiar web browser. Using Gemini, you can explore an online collection of written documents which can link to other written documents. The main difference is that Gemini approaches this task with a strong philosophy of “keep it simple” and “less is enough”. This allows Gemini to simply sidestep, rather than try and probably fail to solve, many of the problems plaguing the modern web, which just seem to get worse and worse no matter how many browser add-ons or well meaning regulations get thrown at them.
Gemini might be of interest to you if you:
- Value your privacy and are opposed to the web’s ubiquitous tracking of users Value your attention and your time and want to read with deep focus, free from distractions
- Are sick and tired of nagging newsletter subscription pop-ups, obnoxious adverts, autoplaying videos that chase you as you scroll and other misfeatures of the modern web
- Live somewhere with slow internet, can’t afford fast internet, or live off-grid and need to conserve precious battery power and minimise expensive satellite data use
- Are a hobbyist programmer with a “do it yourself” attitude who enjoys building their own tools and getting real use out of them every day
If multiple points above apply to you and you’ve been finding the web an increasingly unpleasant place for several years, Gemini might feel like a real breath of fresh air, even an oasis - but it’s not necessarily for everybody. In order to make sure that Gemini remains a simple, lightweight technology which respects its users’ privacy and autonomy not just now but into the future, the feature set has been deliberately kept quite minimal. It’s definitely not too minimal to be useful, but it certainly can’t do everything you might be used to, and maybe it’s missing something that’s a deal-breaker for you. Keep an open mind, give it a try, and see how you feel. Plenty of people have been surprised at how quickly they stop missing things they thought they couldn’t live without!
Another advantage: The active Gemini user community might be small (it is maybe five thousand or ten thousand people). But compared to personal pages on Facebook or Microblog on Ex-Twitter, or Reddit or LinkedIn it has pretty high-quality content from people who like to write in long form, and also like to read. If you write there, the response / resonance will be more like what blogs or LiveJournal was around 2005. A part of this is that many people write in a personal, candid and thoughtful way. Like that Israeli evironmental engineer who wrote how much he hated to be conscripted for military service. And writing is also self-reflection. Like having a rare view into other peoples mind. ou do not find that on facebook.
It is a nice way to host a very lightweight blog or microblog. The ultra-light markup language gives it a feel like a wiki. Such blogs can be viewed with a client like deedum for Android or amfora for Linux, or with a brower using an gemini-to-web gateway: Here a gateway at mozz.us displaying a German paywall-less newspaper at gemini://taz.de.
And by the way, since gemini clients can also do local file:// URLs, it is also a minimum-fuss way to organize a local file tree that contains a mix of documentation / info and media like a wiki, and share it locally with people over NFS or Samba (Windows file sharing).
Doing local peronal notes/wiki in a gemini format is such a cool idea. Thanks.
Deedum has fallen behind and doesn’t support recent android it seems. Same for the only other client in fdroid, Pocket Gopher.
Try Rosy Crow. You’ll have to add the repository to f-droid before you download it.
Here is a list of more recent clients and libraries:
https://github.com/kr1sp1n/awesome-gemini
(good stuff… there is even a FUSE file system for the Gemini protocol.)
Also check out the tildeverse for a true internet experience. Its our little hideaway from bigtech. Where you can truly connect with people.
Do you have a link?
https://tildeverse.org/ is the directory for them all
I think I found it – is this a HTTP/HTML Gateway to it:
https://gemini.tildeverse.org/
The Gemini URL would be
gemini://tildeverse.orgI like this one a lot which is linked there:
gemini://tilde.green
Neat. That’s going nowhere. Less formatting than even markdown… Hey kids you like plain text files right?
Hey kids you like plain text files right?
Me, who grew up reading/referencing text files daily on gamefaqs for cheats, secrets/eggs, and walkthroughs when stuck on various games: Yeh.
Neat.
Yeh
deleted by creator










