Yes, that was one of the main factors. Also the depth and structure of the cave. He was around 100ft/30m below the ground underneath a steep hill. And they’d be drilling into a cave system, not solid ground, meaning there would be a very high risk of a sinkhole/collapse or rock slide. They didn’t just have Jones’s safety to consider, but the safety of rescuers too.
Yeah, IIRC the big preventing factor here was destabilizing the cave and causing a cave-in. Rule 1 of rescue is don’t put yourself in a situation where you need rescuing too.
Okay, okay… different idea! What if we preemptively drug emergent shafts for the caves most likely to collapse?
I’m also wondering if metal detectors are any good to figure out where someone is underground or under rubble? I imagine dogs are better because they use scent, but they can’t sleep through solid layers of rock/ground, could they?
Metal detectors don’t for work much deeper than a meter, and less if there are more minerals in the rock/soil. Smell lingers, so dogs may be able to smell people if they’ve been there hours before and if there’s a small opening the scent can penetrate a collapsed section.
Impossible in the time frame it would have taken to save him, yes. It would have taken days.
Whar would be the limiting factor? Getting the drilling equipment there?
Yes, that was one of the main factors. Also the depth and structure of the cave. He was around 100ft/30m below the ground underneath a steep hill. And they’d be drilling into a cave system, not solid ground, meaning there would be a very high risk of a sinkhole/collapse or rock slide. They didn’t just have Jones’s safety to consider, but the safety of rescuers too.
Yeah, IIRC the big preventing factor here was destabilizing the cave and causing a cave-in. Rule 1 of rescue is don’t put yourself in a situation where you need rescuing too.
Okay, okay… different idea! What if we preemptively drug emergent shafts for the caves most likely to collapse?
I’m also wondering if metal detectors are any good to figure out where someone is underground or under rubble? I imagine dogs are better because they use scent, but they can’t sleep through solid layers of rock/ground, could they?
Then people would climb in different caves. The danger of getting stuck/lost/hurt/dying is part of the attraction to these people
Metal detectors don’t for work much deeper than a meter, and less if there are more minerals in the rock/soil. Smell lingers, so dogs may be able to smell people if they’ve been there hours before and if there’s a small opening the scent can penetrate a collapsed section.
Could maybe use ground-penetrating radar.
searches
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/304157150_Predicting_GPR_Performance_for_Buried_Victim_Search_Rescue
Apparently that’s a thing.
Rescue teams are presumably already using the most-viable option, though, and I generally hear about dogs for hunting under rubble.
God damn autocorrect! Dug* not drug Emergency* not emergent Smell* not sleep
The cave did not collapse.
and also causing a cave in too.